Friday, August 12, 2011

秦日新犯罪情節重大
一、二審判無罪, 高院更一審認定是重罪, 改判半年

 
紅酒案更審 秦日新無罪改判半年


〔記者楊國文、陳慧萍/台北報導〕前駐斐濟代表秦日新,被控任職外交部北美司長期間,主 導以購買紅、白酒方式不實核銷外交業務管理費,一、二審雖判他無罪,但高等法院更一審認為,秦日新是以「變魔術」手法,將發票化整為零,不實核銷支出,犯罪情節重大,昨依公務員登載不實罪,改判秦一年徒刑,因適用減刑條例,減為六月徒刑,且因所犯法條是重罪,不得易科罰金;此案可上訴。
審判長斥塑造「勞績卓著」假象
高 院合議庭審判長童有德宣判時,以罕見嚴厲口吻,指責秦日新在將外派的九十四年十二月整整一個月間,對外國駐台使節等交誼毫無作為,不思改善,竟如「變魔 術」般,將閒置預算購買紅、白酒,並要求商人將發票「化整為零」,捏造宴請美國在台協會副處長葛天豪、加拿大駐台代表侯秉東等人事實,將發票作為「外交業 務管理費」之用,不實登載共十一次之多,並塑造他「勞績卓著」假象,批評對身為外交部北美司長的秦日新而言,犯罪行為已屬重大。
秦日新昨未出庭聆判,律師黃碧芬則無法連繫上,無法得知對判決結果看法或是否上訴,高檢署表示收到判決書,再決定是否上訴;另一被告前外交部北美司科長楊慶輝,已獲檢方緩起訴處分。
外交部長楊進添表示,秦日新僅是少數案例,「希望國人不要把所有外交人員當成過街老鼠」。
高 等法院是依刑法第二一三條的公文書登載不實罪,判秦日新一年徒刑,因適用減刑條例,再減為半年徒刑。不過,因此法條的法定刑是一年以上、七年以下徒刑之 罪,加上秦日新審理期間,堅稱沒有犯罪,實務上通常認定為沒有悔意,因此判決出爐後,引起法界議論紛紛。不具名的多位高院法官認為,以該適用法條論罪的 話,加上審酌秦的身分、犯後態度不佳,此判決輕了一點。某高檢署檢察官則質疑,合議庭判決時,批評秦「犯罪重大,不可等閒視之」,卻判他最低法定刑,實在 讓人看不懂。
民間司改會執行長林?正認為,判秦一年刑責不大合理,內行人都看得出有「暗助」的意味,檢察官應該會上訴最高法院才對。
高院更一審審理發現,秦日新因得知將於九十五年一月十七日派任我國駐紐西蘭代表,但九十四年度北美司「外交業務管理費」仍有廿一萬餘額,指示科長楊慶輝將廿一萬款項購買酒類,供秦赴紐西蘭上任後作為公務贈禮使用。
除昨日判決的紅酒案外,秦日新也因被控詐領眷屬補助款弊案,遭外交部停職,目前由北檢分案偵辦中。

Tuesday, August 2, 2011

International Scholars' open letter to Ma questioning LTH indictment

 
Open letter to President Ma
from 
Thomas Bartlett,
honorary research associate, history program, La Trobe University, Melbourne

Coen Blaauw,
Formosan Association for Public Affairs, Washington

Jean Pierre Cabestan,
professor and head, Department of Government and International Studies, Hong Kong Baptist University

Gordon Chang,
author

Wen-yen Chen,
professor emeritus, University of the District of Columbia, and former president, North American Taiwanese Professors’ Association

Stephane Corcuff,
associate professor of political science, China and Taiwan studies, University of Lyon

Michael Danielsen,
chairman, Taiwan Corner, Copenhagen, Denmark

June Teufel Dreyer,
professor of political science, University of Miami

Norman Getsinger,
US foreign service (retired), The George Washington University graduate program

Terri Giles,
executive director, Formosa Foundation, Los Angeles

Stephen Halsey,
assistant professor of history, University of Miami

Mark Harrison,
senior lecturer, head of the Chinese School of Asian Languages and Studies, University of Tasmania

Michael Rand Hoare,
emeritus reader at the University of London

Christopher Hughes,
professor of international relations, London School of Economics and Political Science

Thomas Hughes,
former chief of staff to late US senator Claiborne Pell, Washington

Bruce Jacobs,
professor of Asian -languages and studies, Monash University, Melbourne

Richard Kagan,
professor emeritus of history, Hamline University, and author

Jerome Keating,
associate professor, National Taipei University (retired), and author

David Kilgour,
former member of the Canadian parliament and secretary of state for Asia-Pacific

Andre Laliberte,
professor, School of Political Studies, University of Ottawa

Perry Link,
professor emeritus of East Asian Studies, Princeton University

Daniel Lynch,
associate professor, School of International Relations, University of Southern California

Victor Mair,
professor of Chinese language and literature, University of Pennsylvania

The Very Reverend
Bruce McLeod,
former president, Canadian Council of Churches, and former moderator, the United Church of Canada

Donald Rodgers,
associate professor of political science, Austin College

Terence Russell,
associate professor of Chinese language and literature, University of Manitoba

Michael Scanlon,
associate professor (retired), Shih Chien University

Christian Schafferer,
associate professor, Department of International Trade, Overseas Chinese Institute, chair of the Austrian Association of East Asian Studies, editor: Journal of Contemporary Eastern Asia

David Schak,
adjunct professor of international business and Asian studies, Griffith University

Michael Stainton,
York Center for Asia Research, Toronto

Peter Tague,
professor of law, Georgetown University

Ross Terrill,
Fairbank Center, Harvard University, and author

Reverend Milo Thornberry,
author

John Tkacik Jr,
US foreign service (retired) and independent commentator, Washington

Arthur Waldron,
lauder professor of international relations, University of Pennsylvania

Gerrit van der Wees,
editor: Taiwan Communique, Washington

Josef Weidenholzer,
Chair, Institute of Social and Societal Policy, Johannes Kepler University of Linz, Austria

Michael Yahuda,
professor emeritus, the London School of Economics, and visiting scholar, George Washington University

Stephen Yates,
president of DC International Advisory and former deputy assistant to the vice president for National Security Affairs
Dear President Ma Ying-jeou (馬英九),
We the undersigned, international academics, analysts and writers from the US, Canada, Europe and Australia, have for many years been keen observers of political developments in Taiwan. We were delighted when Taiwan made its transition to democracy in the late 1980s and early 1990s, and we continue to care deeply for the country and its future as a free and democratic nation-state.
However, during the past three years, many of us have felt it necessary to address publicly our concerns to you about the erosion of justice and democracy in Taiwan, most recently in April this year regarding the charges of the “36,000 missing documents” against a number of prominent former Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) officials. We raised these issues as international supporters of Taiwan’s democracy.
At this time we express our deep concern about the charges against former president Lee Teng-hui (李登輝), often referred to as “the father of Taiwan’s democracy,” who was indicted on June 30 on charges of allegedly channeling US$7.8 million from secret diplomatic funds into the Taiwan Research Institute. These charges and their timing raise a number of questions that are related both to the case itself and the integrity of the judicial system in Taiwan.
First, why did the prosecutors decide to pursue these charges at this time? The events allegedly occurred in the years 1994 and 1995, about 16 years ago. We have difficulty believing that prosecutors discovered evidence only recently, particularly in view of the fact that key evidence cited by the prosecutors was dismissed by a Supreme Court ruling in 2006 in a case involving former National Security Bureau chief accountant Hsu Ping-chiang (徐炳強), who was charged in connection with the missing diplomatic funds. Are these charges perhaps more directly related to the former president’s outspokenness on current political issues, and in particular to the upcoming presidential election?
The second issue is one of evenhandedness: The problem with the administration of secret diplomatic funds appears to be systemic, primarily because of the lack of transparency associated with the funds and vague guidelines for their use. Hence, if the former president is now charged, should fairness not demand that there be investigations, and charges, against other high officials who served at the same time, such as the vice president, premier and provincial governor, who had similar discretionary funds available to them?
The third issue relates to the impartiality of the judicial system. Since November 2008, there have been a number of indictments and charges against former DPP officials and others who were and are critical of your government. The case against Lee appears to be part of a deeply disturbing trend to use the judiciary against political opponents. While there is an obvious need to uphold the law in a democracy, this needs to be done fairly and evenhandedly, with no hint or appearance of any partiality.
Mr President, as head of state you bear overall responsibility for the state of affairs in Taiwan. In democratic systems, proper checks and balances between the executive, legislative and judiciary branches are of the utmost importance. The executive and the legislative branches have a responsibility to exercise oversight and to balance activism in the judiciary, just as the judiciary serves a similar role with regard to the executive and legislative branches. Stating that your government abides by “judicial independence” is therefore not enough. It is essential that all participants in the judicial process — prosecutors, judges and lawyers — are fully imbued with the basic principle that the judiciary is scrupulously impartial and not given to any partisan preferences.

We, as members of the international academic community, are left with the impression that the indictments and practices of the judiciary in Taiwan over the past three years reflect a judicial system that is increasingly influenced by political considerations. There has been a regression in the accomplishments of Taiwan’s momentous democratization of the 1990s and 2000s. As good friends of Taiwan, we are deeply unsettled by this. It undermines Taiwan’s international image as a free and democratic nation.
Mr President, we therefore urge you and your government to ensure that the judicial system is held to the highest standards of objectivity and fairness. Taiwan has many challenges ahead of it and it cannot afford the political divisions created by the use of the judicial system for political purposes.
Respectfully yours,
Thomas Bartlett,
honorary research associate, history program, La Trobe University, Melbourne
Coen Blaauw,
Formosan Association for Public Affairs, Washington
Jean Pierre Cabestan,
professor and head, Department of Government and International Studies, Hong Kong Baptist University
Gordon Chang,
author
Wen-yen Chen,
professor emeritus, University of the District of Columbia, and former president, North American Taiwanese Professors’ Association
Stephane Corcuff,
associate professor of political science, China and Taiwan studies, University of Lyon
Michael Danielsen,
chairman, Taiwan Corner, Copenhagen, Denmark
June Teufel Dreyer,
professor of political science, University of Miami
Norman Getsinger,
US foreign service (retired), The George Washington University graduate program
Terri Giles,
executive director, Formosa Foundation, Los Angeles
Stephen Halsey,
assistant professor of history, University of Miami
Mark Harrison,
senior lecturer, head of the Chinese School of Asian Languages and Studies, University of Tasmania
Michael Rand Hoare,
emeritus reader at the University of London
Christopher Hughes,
professor of international relations, London School of Economics and Political Science
Thomas Hughes,
former chief of staff to late US senator Claiborne Pell, Washington
Bruce Jacobs,
professor of Asian -languages and studies, Monash University, Melbourne
Richard Kagan,
professor emeritus of history, Hamline University, and author
Jerome Keating,
associate professor, National Taipei University (retired), and author
David Kilgour,
former member of the Canadian parliament and secretary of state for Asia-Pacific
Andre Laliberte,
professor, School of Political Studies, University of Ottawa
Perry Link,
professor emeritus of East Asian Studies, Princeton University
Daniel Lynch,
associate professor, School of International Relations, University of Southern California
Victor Mair,
professor of Chinese language and literature, University of Pennsylvania
The Very Reverend
Bruce McLeod,
former president, Canadian Council of Churches, and former moderator, the United Church of Canada
Donald Rodgers,
associate professor of political science, Austin College
Terence Russell,
associate professor of Chinese language and literature, University of Manitoba
Michael Scanlon,
associate professor (retired), Shih Chien University
Christian Schafferer,
associate professor, Department of International Trade, Overseas Chinese Institute, chair of the Austrian Association of East Asian Studies, editor: Journal of Contemporary Eastern Asia
David Schak,
adjunct professor of international business and Asian studies, Griffith University
Michael Stainton,
York Center for Asia Research, Toronto
Peter Tague,
professor of law, Georgetown University
Ross Terrill,
Fairbank Center, Harvard University, and author
Reverend Milo Thornberry,
author
John Tkacik Jr,
US foreign service (retired) and independent commentator, Washington
Arthur Waldron,
lauder professor of international relations, University of Pennsylvania
Gerrit van der Wees,
editor: Taiwan Communique, Washington
Josef Weidenholzer,
Chair, Institute of Social and Societal Policy, Johannes Kepler University of Linz, Austria
Michael Yahuda,
professor emeritus, the London School of Economics, and visiting scholar, George Washington University
Stephen Yates,
president of DC International Advisory and former deputy assistant to the vice president for National Security Affairs

Saturday, July 23, 2011

台灣司法: 罪不及馬英九, 朋友及家奴

 
馬英九把公款存進私人帳戶, 無罪.  賣國, 不辨.
郝龍斌, 楊志良, 胡志強, ... 儘皆無罪.
李慶安案而今 1,229 天! 
呂財益招供了﹕是國民黨立委安排海關集體收賄!

2011-07-09 星洲日報報導:
海關副總局長呂財益週四應訊時已坦承收受鮑魚、燕窩等禮品,但辯稱是“業者送年菜”;
對於業者招待飲宴,呂財益還反嗆法官:“立委安排,能不去嗎?”

呂財益招認的安排海關集體貪污的立委,就是國民黨立委李復興.因為李復興助理張勝泰已經同案被收押.

年底就要選立委了,國民黨立委涉嫌這麼大的貪污案,卻不見台灣媒體大幅報導.這麼爆炸性的新聞,
竟只有星洲日報報導.檢調成功地把注意力轉移到海關收賄官員呂財益身上.頂多只是讓國民黨立委
助理張勝泰個人扛起刑責.好像竹聯幫作案,總是派小弟出面,老大躲在後面收錢;國民黨A錢也一樣,
派立委助理出面扛責,大咖的都躲在後面分贓.

其實國民黨立委關說或安排海關收賄,已經是慣犯,而且劣績累累.
2010-4-23 海關稽查組股長唐隆生涉嫌貪污;護航台北市「森之鄉」公司負責人張世群
自疫區日本夾帶高價松阪牛肉入境轉售,數量初估近五噸,獲利至少四千五百萬元。
案情目前還在向上發展中,但已知國民黨立委陳淑慧,國民黨立委朱鳳芝也是涉嫌派助理
到海關關說,安排唐隆生等官員, 讓張世群夾帶非法牛肉入境!

去年2010高雄海關旅客多帶菸,國民黨立委林益世也立刻向海關講情.

昨天石礦公會總幹事陳富臺驚爆同業近年來搶進中國非法石材 行賄海關達30億 ﹗
講完話,今天陳富臺人已失蹤,聽說黑道在追他.使用非法中國石材製品的公共工程,
包括國防部博愛專案新建工程,中市政新建大樓,台北市政府內湖公園整建工程,南港捷運站工程...等.
泛藍執政的政府公共工程進口中國非法石材,會沒有國民黨立委勾結海關賺那30億嗎﹖

Thursday, July 21, 2011

陳明文案: 廠商賴文正當庭翻供,否認陳明文洩漏底價給他,指稱是調查員跟他協商,要他這樣說,就讓他交保,他說起訴書指控都是子虛烏有

 
Who is behind the framing of 陳明文?
陳明文涉圖利案 廠商推翻自白
 
〔記者余雪蘭/嘉市報導〕民進黨立委陳明文被控嘉義縣長任內辦理民雄污水處理設施工程時,涉嫌洩密圖利偉盟公司,嘉義地院昨開庭進行準備程序,廠商賴文正當庭翻供,否認陳明文洩漏底價給他,指稱是調查員跟他協商,要他這樣說,就讓他交保,他說起訴書指控都是子虛烏有。

檢方:為其他被告卸責

蒞庭論辯的主任檢察官陳昭廷,駁斥賴文正的說法,指他推翻自白是為其他被告卸責,並指陳殿寶辯解所說的預算金額與公開的資料不符合。
嘉義地檢署九十七年十月以陳明文涉嫌不法,展開偵查,(先把他抓來關) 經過二年五個月的偵查,於今年三月十一日以涉嫌洩密、圖利等罪嫌起訴陳明文、賴文正及承辦該工程的前嘉義縣府水利處長陳殿寶,賴文正與陳殿寶並被控涉嫌行賄評選委員。
嘉 義地院昨天首度開庭,陳殿寶否認洩漏預算書內容及評選委員名單給賴文正,並說採購法規定預算金額得在招標公告中一併公開,七.九三億的預算金額並非保密項 目。陳殿寶為澄清事實,自曝緋聞,指稱賴文正拿三百萬元給他,是借給他去處理自己的緋聞案,並非要行賄評選委員,而他去拜訪韓教授,是怕評選委員出席人數 不夠。
賴文正也全盤翻供,強調該工程為公開競標,由出價最便宜者得標,根本沒有必要行賄評選委員,而施做該工程,會計結算顯示偉盟虧損,何來圖利?
至於起訴書說賴文正供稱陳明文向他洩漏底價,賴表示是調查員把他叫到偵訊室外面,以交保做為條件,要他這樣講,結果事後他被收押,其彰化鄉親抗議,檢察官跑到看守所找他談,後來才讓他交保。
賴文正說,檢察官為何不依程序提訊他,而是跑去看守所私下找他談,且交保隔了二年多,檢察官都沒再傳訊他就起訴。

Wednesday, July 20, 2011

彭百顯: 921十年冤案證明乃濫權誣陷!

 
彭百顯:  921十年冤案證明乃濫權誣陷!

  「921貪污弊案」是檢調製造的歷史冤案,包括本人擔任南投縣長被起訴之九案以及啟動本案起訴縣府主管的「俄羅斯原木案」、「震災週年重建成果展案」,所有本人主政當時與震災捐款及重建有關遭起訴的縣政府公務人員、諮詢顧問,如今,皆已無罪定讞。事實證明,921冤案暴露也控訴檢調單位枉顧災區重建迫切,侵犯行政權,違法濫權、誤用司法、惡意栽贓、傷害當事人名譽。
    檢調以種種荒謬、錯誤甚至偽造的依據,羈押本人61天, 並控訴本人「圖利」、「期約不正利益」、「侵占公用公有財物」、「詐取財物」、「侵占、偽造文書」、「背信」等多項「貪污」罪名,更以在緊急命令期間,指控本人「身為縣長不知戮力造福鄉民」為由,加重求刑二十年。
    本人被起訴的九案中,災後測設及檢測樁工程13件、基金會借支私人、立委任內捐款、基金會投資等四案,均於2004年無罪定讞;民眾捐款予基金會兩案於2006年無罪定讞;至於被訴圖利的三項工程案,十一年來,所有歷審法官均判決圖利無罪,只有更一審法官草率行事,不但違法未進行審理、查證,而且,全然漠視前審地院及高院經已分別查實更正原起訴書之錯誤而判決無罪的事實,竟照抄原本錯誤的起訴書及經證明為虛偽造假之筆錄,改以圖利判處五年半,實荒謬至極;但這些工程案件離奇的一直在所謂「違反政府採購法」中打轉,法院以承平時期政府採購法來論斷依緊急命令所辦理之限制性招標,根本不瞭解當時震災重建急迫性,違背時空認知。終經更二審、更三審合議庭明察秋毫判決被訴圖利(含政府採購法)均無罪,並經最高法院於2011年7月14日判決駁回檢察官上訴,921冤案終得以全部無罪定讞,還本人清白。
檢視921冤案,檢方舉罪不正義,證據薄弱且偽造筆錄,公信力蕩然無存。尤不可思議的,調查局公文對偵訊錄影帶公然說謊、竄改時間,以瞞騙審理法院及當事人,扭曲事實,刻意冤枉,實令人不齒。本人在南投地院審理庭兩年多時間一再申請調閱偵訊錄影帶;其間,調查局竟提供一卷有影無聲之偵訊錄影帶(聲稱麥克風燒壞),並膽敢偽造公文,謊稱日期弄錯。本人於高院審理時同樣再請求調閱,後調查局改稱「前因故未尋獲」,始予提供另五卷影帶。經勘驗這些偵訊錄影帶,發現縣府921臨時辦公大樓工程案起訴的主要依據,竟是偽造的調查筆錄,逃亡中國之秘密證人筆錄竟有高達六成均係偽造,以此作為起訴證據,膽大妄為,違背法理。
    另在高院審理勘驗偵訊錄影帶中,證實調查員多處以脅迫、利誘等不正方法取供,甚至偽造筆錄。包括調查局竟將全段問話,全部移花接木為證人證詞以作為誣陷本人之佐證證據;並有證人供稱「檢調單位唆使作偽證」,而且,檢方據以起訴之調查筆錄,內容竟是調查員所加;甚至有被告在偵訊恐嚇壓力下作不實之陳述;更有檢調人員在偵訊時態度惡劣怒喝指明說要辦縣長,又威脅要收押恐嚇當事人。可惡可惱檢調如此造作矛盾、公然虛偽作假,誣陷他人。
    檢察官擁有神聖權威的起訴權,但本案卻暴露檢察官無證據卻濫權起訴,誤用神聖公權。921臨辦大樓工程案中,檢察官起訴本人利用職權「擅自變更地目」、「追加預算」,證實檢察官看不懂工程預算書、不懂權狀地目。按本案地目從未變更,且總預算減少,工程發包金額1億6,050萬元,結算1億4,638萬餘元,起訴書白紙黑字指控「工程追加4,800萬元,圖利廠商1,000萬元」,荒謬離譜。而巨型公園工程案,檢察官亦弄不清楚招標作業與標單內容,以錯誤認知起訴圖利罪,其他案件之起訴內容也同樣錯誤百出。檢察官究竟是為業績壓力,抑或另有緣由,竟然可以如此盲目起訴?但素質如此,令人不敢領教。
    回顧本案歷史時空,本人自上任縣長以來,政治對手即有計畫性地透過坊間散佈謠言、抹黑中傷,無所不用其極。至921災難時期更變本加厲,921冤案所暴露檢察官濫權依謠言草率辦案之誣陷,令人痛心。這段災難重建的坎坷歷程與政治操作,深深打擊滄桑的南投災區,對身處貧窮的乞丐縣尤為艱辛,這些人為造端終而釀製921冤案。十一年間,冤案纏訟,連累許多重建廠商倒閉、員工失業,受冤者身心重創、家庭破碎、傾家蕩產,本人一生清譽也盡喪於莫須有。雖然,我始終堅信正道、公道是人間最可貴的真理,司法正義終將還我公道,但人生信譽卻已被摧殘。國家司法公器所製造冤案的蹂躪傷害更難評量。如今,事情已過,真相亦白。我深深體認,智慧無法傳承是災難最大的代價,因為藉由災難修成的苦果,彌足珍貴。
(作者為前南投縣長,開南大學財務金融學系副教授)


Wednesday, July 6, 2011

林保華: 一路走來介入司法的馬總統

 

在前總統李登輝與未來總統蔡英文七一同台“棄馬保台”前夕,馬總統御
用打手的特偵組宣佈對李前總統起訴,消息震撼國內外,連藍營內部也受
波及,可見事態之非同尋常。也由於反應過於惡劣,大出馬集團意料,所
以馬總統親自召開記者會,重申尊重司法、不干預個案立場,對在野黨譴
責此案是政府選舉操作,政治追殺,挾怨報復,肅清異己,馬英九聲稱絕
無此事,也絕對不容許這種事情在台灣發生云云。他還表示對此一路走來
始終如一;對於在野黨泛政治的批評,感到非常遺憾。

其實“非常遺憾”的是記者,因為馬總統照本宣科不到兩分鐘即匆匆離去
,不給記者提問,解答他們的疑惑。不知道堂堂大總統怕什麼?是不是心
裡有鬼,擔心在記者提問下露出馬腳?

馬總統果然是一路走來不介入司法嗎?僅舉幾例就可知那是一路走來的謊
言:

2006年6月18日,已經出任國民黨主席而積極準備競選總統的馬英九,在
各大報刊登半版《答案,在天下父母的心中!》的廣告,赤裸裸的恐嚇檢
調人員說:“如果現在的檢察系統迫於政治壓力,為貪污護航,甚至成為
貪污者的共犯,以後政黨輪替,這些貪污弊案重啟偵查程序,責任歸屬恐
怕是必須認真考慮的後果。” 

馬英九同一天在彰化舉行的群眾大會上,再度公開喊話強調,民進黨不會
永遠執政,有一天政黨輪替,“所有人做過的事,都有受檢驗的機會。”
“現在不是卅年風水輪流轉,四年就會風水輪流轉”。馬英九明目張膽恐
嚇司法,進行“秋後算帳”的威脅。

果然,馬英九因為將特別費轉入妻子周美青的私人帳戶而在2007年2月被
檢調起訴後,馬英九在13日發表聲明,恐嚇這是“邪痞者梟叫狼嗥”,謾
罵相關檢調人員是“邪痞”與“梟狼”。

於是,當起訴失敗後,起訴他的檢察官侯寬仁,雖然因為以前是在法務部
長馬英九領導之下而手下留情,馬英九還是挾怨報復,竟然對侯寬仁進行
提告。這種公然對司法人員的打擊報復,在政壇上極為罕見。那是馬英九
再次公開警告司法人員不准在馬太歲頭上動土,也不可抗命。

馬英九出任總統後,放縱特偵組對陳水扁前總統的審訊,包括上手銬及以
“輿論”對檢調施壓,甚至半途改變審判長以得到判決的預期效果。尤其
在2010年11月6日,二次金改案一審判決陳水扁等21人被告無罪,馬英九
7日先假惺惺表示表示,他不評論進行中的司法個案,卻又意有所指地指
出,“司法不能孤立於社會,也不能背離人民對司法合理的期待。”於是
特偵組主任陳宏達立即表示,近期內將針對二次金改案提起上訴。

馬英九介入司法的立竿見影之效還在於,幾天後的11月10日,陳水扁夫婦
涉及的龍潭購地案定讞,他們都被判11年徒刑,陳敏薰則判處8年徒刑。
國民黨立委、馬團隊成員吳育昇就表示,這項判決推翻了二次金改案周占
春法官的無罪判決,等於“打了周占春的判決一巴掌”。

除了這些,去年司法院正副院長的中途任免、今年大法官的提名爆發“恐
龍法官”風波,都一再顯出馬英九手影。馬英九以總統之尊直接、間接介
入司法,使台灣本來已經非常具有“黨性”的司法,更加失去其獨立性。
現在爆出起訴李前總統事件,馬英九又豈能逃避干預之嫌?連他一貫說的
“看報才知道”,這次也沒有說了,可見他早就知道,不是策劃者,也是
批准或默認者,逃是逃不掉的。

而這一切,當然是為了明年的選舉,把李前總統、陳前總統、蔡未來總統
拉成“貪腐集團”,一棍子打死。只是由於過去惡性太多、行跡太露,結
果可能是“機關算盡太聰明,反誤了卿卿性命。”
《極光》電子報  2011.7.4